Your Hometown Jeweler in Bloomington Indiana

Proudly serving south-central Indiana for over sixty-three years, Victor Settle Jewelry is family owned and operated with an emphasis on friendly, personal service and consumer education. We feature innovative and classic jewelry and timepiece designs as well as quality repair and remount services. Visit our comfortable showroom, and let our staff help you choose that special gift that is sure to become a treasured heirloom.
Being an independent jeweler gives us infinite choices in what we can offer. Our biggest restriction is the physical size of our showroom, so we pack it with styles ranging from classic to contemporary. We ARE the small store with the big selection! Settle Jewelry is very much a "bricks and mortar" retailer, with no immediate plans to add e-commerce to our variety of services, but we invite you to preview selections from some of our favorite vendors. MUCH more is in store, and if you don't see it, please ask. We are here for you!
As diamond and jewelry experts, we’ve taken our commitment to the next level by becoming direct diamond importers. We travel to the world’s largest market in Antwerp, Belgium, to personally select many of the diamonds for sale at our store. Through this process, we’re able to offer a magnificent collection of diamonds at significant savings. Take advantage of our diamond concierge service during our next excursion.
A cooperative owned by its members, RJO requires its jewelers to meet the highest standards in the industry for honesty and integrity. RJO brings together leading manufacturers from around the world to two buying shows each year, giving us access to the finest jewelry and all-important first looks at new trends.